The Core Difference
APR (annual percentage rate) is the rate per period times the number of periods, ignoring that interest stacks. APY (annual percentage yield) is what actually accumulates over a year after compounding. A 1% monthly rate is 12% APR but 12.68% APY, because each month's interest earns interest in the months after it.
APY = (1 + APR/n)n − 1
with n compounding periods per year. 6% APR compounded monthly: (1.005)12 − 1 = 6.17% APY. Compounded daily: 6.18%. As n grows, APY creeps up but never runs away - the gap is fractions of a percent, not whole percents.
The Legal Asymmetry Nobody Explains
US rules use the two letters deliberately differently depending on who's quoting you:
- Deposits (Truth in Savings): banks must advertise APY - the flattering-to-saver number that includes compounding.
- Loans and credit cards (Truth in Lending): lenders must disclose APR - which for credit cards is a periodic-rate snapshot that understates what compounding will actually cost you over a year.
So the 24.99% APR on a card statement, if you carry the balance all year with monthly compounding, costs an effective 28.08%. Not a scam - just letters doing different jobs on different sides of the counter.
Practical Consequences
- Comparing two savings accounts with different compounding schedules: compare APYs, full stop. The higher APY always wins, whatever the quoted APRs say.
- Comparing loans: same-terms APRs compare fairly, but APR includes origination fees and doesn't capture monthly compounding - for an all-in cost, project actual payments in the compound interest calculator or total-payments view.
- Monthly vs daily compounding at the same APR is worth about 0.01-0.1% a year. Chasing a better compounding schedule is a rounding-error hobby; chasing a better rate is not.
Try the Sensitivity Yourself
Enter a rate in the converter above and switch only the compounding frequency - watch how little APY moves. Then change the rate itself, and watch how much it moves. One number you negotiate beats ten numbers you optimize.